Sign In or Register
  • Home
  • Contact
  • Rss Feed
11.05.2012 Serbia Trademarks German Pet Food Manufacturer Wins Bad Faith Trademark Case against Serbian Company PETOSEVIC PETOSEVIC

On December 15, 2011, the Commercial Appellate Court in Belgrade, Serbia ruled against the Serbian pet food importer and producer who registered and used two trademarks belonging to its business partner, the German company Gimborn, which manufactures and distributes various brands of cat, dog and small animal food and care products. The Commercial Appellate Court thus upheld the 2010 first-instance ruling of the Commercial Court in Belgrade.

In 2003, the defendant, the Serbian company, registered trademarks Gimpet (No. 49583) and Gimborn (No. 49584) with the Serbian IPO, in the same Class 31 in which the plaintiff, the German company, registered international trademarks under IR No. 591166 (Gimborn) in 1992 and IR No. 506326 (Gimpet) in 1986. The plaintiff’s marks, however, did not gain protection in Serbia until 2007, following a request for subsequent designation.

During court proceedings, the plaintiff argued that he had been using the trademarks in commerce all over the world, including the former Yugoslavia, later Serbia and Montenegro and then Serbia, to mark Class 31 products, long before the defendant’s registration of the infringing marks with the Serbian IPO in 2003. The plaintiff also argued that the defendant knew the plaintiff was using identical or highly similar marks in Serbia as the defendant started buying, importing and selling plaintiff’s products on the territory of Serbia and Montenegro in 2001. The plaintiff thus accused the defendant of intentionally taking unfair advantage of the reputation of the trademarks.

Even though the plaintiff’s trademarks were entitled to protection within Article 6bis of the Paris Convention for Protection of Industrial Property (well-known marks), the plaintiff refrained from providing evidence for determining whether the marks are well known, as the plaintiff believed the legal basis for the case is contained in Article 66 of the local trademark law.

The defendant argued that he had been producing his own pet food with brand names Gimborn and Gimpet since 1993. He emphasized that the plaintiff’s trademarks were not registered and protected on the territory of Serbia in 2003, when the Serbian IPO granted him the registrations. The defendant also challenged the plaintiff’s argument according to which the defendant wanted to take advantage of the plaintiff’s reputation, by claiming that in Serbia very few pet owners feed their pets industrially prepared pet food. The defendant stressed that the plaintiff did not show that the marks are well known.

The court took into consideration the similarities between the goods involved, the similarity of the marks as well as the correspondence the two parties exchanged in the period 2001-2004, which proved that the parties were involved in a business relationship when the defendant filed an application for the registration of the two marks in 2003. The court therefore ruled that the defendant knew about the existence of the plaintiff’s marks and that the defendant registered them and used them in bad faith. The court ordered the defendant to pay the plaintiff’s lawsuit fees in the amount of approximately EUR 1,500 (USD 2,000).

The court based its decision on Article 66 of Serbia and Montenegro’s Law on Trademarks (Official Gazette No. 61/2004 and 7/2005) which states that if a trademark is filed in bad faith, the rightful owner can ask for the mark to be transferred into his/her name.

On April 27, 2010, the defendant filed an appeal with the Commercial Appelate Court, but the court upheld the previous 2010 ruling. The final court decision entered into force on February 20, 2012.

You can find the original text here.

Intelectual property related news

01.07.2010 OHIM Trademarks The Trademarks and Designs registration office of the European Union Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency
01.07.2010 WIPO Trademarks The World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) is a specialized agency of the United Nations Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency
01.07.2010 Romania Trademarks New Trademark Law in Romania Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency Teodoru & Associates Intellectual Property Agency
17.11.2010 Libya Trademarks New Trademark Law has been enacted in Libya Hoda Abdel Hadi & Parteners
04.04.2011 Bulgaria Trademarks Trademark registration in Bulgaria IUSAUTHOR law office, Bulgaria IUSAUTHOR law office, Bulgaria
12.04.2011 OHIM Trademarks Community Trademark (CTM) Conversion into national EU trademarks Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
19.04.2011 Viet Nam Trademarks A success story about appealing: trademark "GITI" PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
20.04.2011 Viet Nam Trademarks A success case: opposition against the registration of trademark "MAVIC" PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
01.06.2011 Japan Trademarks TIPO grants full reinstatement to patent, trademark applications delayed due to 3/11 Japanese earthquake ESSEN Patent & Trademark Office
01.06.2011 China Trademarks China Boasts Second Sharpest Growth in International Trademarks Registration ESSEN Patent & Trademark Office
01.06.2011 China Trademarks Adidas Three Stripes Setback in Beijing ESSEN Patent & Trademark Office
14.06.2011 China Trademarks Experts in Various Fields Discussed Parallel Importation Issue, INTA Round Table Successfully Held in Unitalen UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Trademarks Trademark Infringement and Unfair Competition Case against Shenzhen ?Century Baoma? Represented by Unitalen Elected as the“Ten Best Practices in Intellectual Property Protection in 2009 of the Supreme People’s Court? UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
17.11.2010 Canada Patents Canada’s Federal Court Overturns Patent Office’s Attempts to Exclude Business Methods from Patent Protection On Oyen Wiggs Green & Mutala Llp Oyen Wiggs Green & Mutala Llp
25.05.2011 Brazil Patents THE OPPORTUNITIES ARE FOR ALL César A. Leão Barcellos & Cia.Ltd.
01.06.2011 Taiwan, Province of China Patents Revision to Examination Guidelines for Amendments of Granted Patent is now in effect ESSEN Patent & Trademark Office
01.06.2011 Taiwan, Province of China Patents Taiwan passes draft amendment to Patent Act ESSEN Patent & Trademark Office
14.06.2011 China Patents Partner Ping Gu Attended Utility Models and Design Patents Roundtable Jointly Sponsored by AIPLA and USPTO UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Patents Beijing Chang Ping District Amply Rewarded Hi-Tech Companies and Technicians, Unitalen Was Given the Award for Excellent Agency UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Patents Unitalen’s Guangzhou Branch Co-sponsored IP training with Guangdong IP Bureau UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Patents Officials of Beijing Intellectual Property Bureau conducted research in UNITALEN UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
17.11.2010 Bangladesh Copyright It appears that the rationale, working and benefits of copyright and related right are not sufficiently understood in Bangladesh, Islam & Co
14.06.2011 China Domain names Unitalen Won Domain Name Disputes for World-famous Companies UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
20.06.2011 Bangladesh Trademarks Trademark Classes K. A. BARI & CO. K. A. BARI & CO.
22.06.2011 China Trademarks International IP Forum Gorodissky & Partners Gorodissky & Partners
27.06.2011 Russian Federation Trademarks Publication at WTR Magazine Gorodissky & Partners Gorodissky & Partners
29.06.2011 Russian Federation Trademarks Statistics Gorodissky & Partners Gorodissky & Partners
05.07.2011 Russian Federation Trademarks Teflon Proves Its Strength Gorodissky & Partners Gorodissky & Partners
13.07.2011 Russian Federation Trademarks World Trademark Review Yearbook 2011: RUSSIA Gorodissky & Partners Gorodissky & Partners
02.08.2011 India Trademarks Indian Trade Marks Office Provides Updated List of Missing Registered Trade Mark files for each Branch Tech Corp Legal LLP

Intelectual property related articles

13.03.2011 Sri Lanka Trademarks Intellectual property law in Sri Lanka Dissanayake M Sunil Intellectual Property
13.03.2011 Sri Lanka Patents Patents in Sri Lanka Dissanayake M Sunil Intellectual Property
13.03.2011 Sri Lanka Designs Industrial Designs in Sri Lanka Dissanayake M Sunil Intellectual Property
13.03.2011 Sri Lanka Copyright Copy right in Sri Lanka Dissanayake M Sunil Intellectual Property
28.03.2011 Mongolia Trademarks Filling Trade mark in Mongolia EB
03.04.2011 China Patents Guide to Filing a PCT Patent Application Entering the Chinese National Phase/Stage Borsam Intellectual Property-China IP Attorneys,PRC Lawyers
06.04.2011 WIPO Domain names Worldwide registration of domain names - useful link to check and register domain names; domain name disputes. Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
06.04.2011 Viet Nam Trademarks Requirements for Trademark Registration in Vietnam PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
06.04.2011 Viet Nam Designs Requirements for Registering a Design in Vietnam PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
06.04.2011 Viet Nam Trademarks Trademark Opposition/Appeal in Vietnam PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
06.04.2011 Viet Nam Patents Patent Opposition/Appeal in Vietnam PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd. PADEMARK Intellectual Property Co. Ltd.
06.04.2011 Bangladesh Trademarks Trademark Registration Process In Bangladesh Munshi And Associates
07.04.2011 Azerbaijan Trademarks Accelerated examination of trademark application B. Khalilov & Co. B. Khalilov & Co.
11.04.2011 Peru Trademarks Trademark in Action ESTUDIO DELION ESTUDIO DELION
11.04.2011 Peru Trademarks Proof of use of mixed and figurative marks ESTUDIO DELION ESTUDIO DELION
12.04.2011 Bangladesh Trademarks TRADE MARK REGISTRATION PROCESS IN BANGLADESH MUNSHI & ASSOCIATES IP LAW FIRM
12.04.2011 OHIM Trademarks CTM Conversions into national EU trademarks Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
25.05.2011 Brazil Trademarks THE TRADEMARKS IN NON USE OR ABANDONED César A. Leão Barcellos & Cia.Ltd.
08.06.2011 United States Copyright Copyright Compliance in Private Companies: Challenges & Solutions Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
08.06.2011 United States Patents Medicines Patent Pool: Facilitating Access to HIV Treatment Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
08.06.2011 Romania Patents IP Outreach: Cooperation Yields Results in Romania (by Bogdan Boreschievici, Mariana Mosoianu, Stefana Teodorov and Maria-Magdalena Dobre) Intellektus Network LTD Intellektus Network LTD
14.06.2011 China Patents The Influence of New Patent Law and Interpretation on Patent Enforcement in China UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Patents Patent Strategies for Foreign R&D companies UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
14.06.2011 China Trademarks Trademark Right Enforcement in China?Comparing with US trademark right enforcement UNITALEN Attorneys At Law
01.07.2011 Bulgaria Designs ‘PROTECTION OF THE PRODUCT INNOVATIONS AS INDUSTRIAL DESIGNS IN BULGARIA’ Office IPR Office IPR
06.07.2011 Myanmar Trademarks Trademark Protection and its enforcement in Myanmar U Nyunt Tin Associates Intellectual Property Law Firm U Nyunt Tin Associates Intellectual Property Law Firm
02.08.2011 India Patents Local working requirements and enforceability of patents: an Indian perspective of challenges and opportunities surrounding a granted patent" as Published in Asia Pacific Regional Forum Newsletter of the International Bar Association (IBA) Legal Practice Tech Corp Legal LLP
03.08.2011 Peru Trademarks Preventing hidden commercialisation of GM foods ESTUDIO DELION ESTUDIO DELION
08.02.2013 Peru Trademarks DETAINING SUSPECT GOODS ESTUDIO DELION ESTUDIO DELION
09.09.2013 Peru Trademarks CONFUSION OVER APPELLATIONS OF ORIGIN ESTUDIO DELION ESTUDIO DELION